Monster
Mash: The Greatest “Verses” Films in Horror
What’s better than a horror movie?
Two horror movies! And what’s better than two horror movies? Two horror movies
rolled into one! The monster mash, the peanut butter and jelly of horror
movies, has been around for 80 years.
Used most effectively by Universal in the 40s and Toho in the 60s, the
monster vs monster formula still has the potential to give fans what they want,
mainly their favorite horror creations from various films and genres all under
one roof. What follows is a list of some
of the greatest monster vs. monster films out there.
25) Monster Brawl (2011)- This is less a narrative
story and more of a live action fighting game. With almost no plot, the film
simply features fights between various monsters in WWE style bouts. The film
will probably leave most horror fans scratching their heads but there are a few
that would like this, mainly those fans of professional wrestling and fighting
games. Several real-life wrestling performers appear (including Kevin Nash and
Jimmy “Mouth of the South” Hart). Somehow, the makers of this film got Lance
Henrikson to lend his gravelly voice, doling out occasional Mortal Kombat style
commentary.
24) Dr. Jekyll y el Hombre Lobo (Dr Jekyll and the
Wolfman) (1971) -The first of many Paul Naschy films to appear on this list,
this is a pretty ingenious idea that I’m surprised Universal never thought of,
as both Mr. Hyde and the Wolf Man involve the unleashing of our darker, bestial
sides. Naschy plays both Mr. Hyde and the Wolf Man with veteran horror actor
Jack Taylor as Dr. Jekyll. A solid film that fans of Spanish horror will enjoy.23) The Creeps (1997)-If you were a Gen X fan of
horror, Full Moon Pictures was the best thing going from the late 80s through
the 90s. Their movies were usually low budget, but never looked like it, and as
they were skipping the theatres and marketing straight to the video store, they
usually had some creative ideas. A plot that is too convoluted to bother with
involves a mad scientist trying to bring to life history’s greatest monsters;
Dracula, the Frankenstein Monster, the Mummy and the Wolf Man. He succeeds, but
the process goes awry and the monsters are created as 3 foot tall versions of
themselves. The pack of pint sized terrors is led by Dracula, played by veteran
genre actor Phil Fondacaro (Willow, Bordello of Blood, Troll, Dollman vs
Demonic Toys (which appears later on this list) and about a million other
things.22) La Maldicion de la Bestia (Night of the Howling Beast)
(1975)- Another Paul Naschy film with him as the Wolf Man. In this
installment, his doomed protagonist finds himself in the Himalayas. There is a circuitous plot involving a group
of mountain witches and an army of bandits, but what lands the film on this
list is the finale which features Naschy’s Wolf Man fighting the Abominable
Snow Man (aka the Yeti).21)-Destroy All Monsters (1968)- Most Godzilla films
feature Godzilla vs other monsters. Often these monsters are created just for that film, but
occasionally other monsters are imported from other franchises. The Shōwa
period of Godzilla films (i.e. the 60s and 70s) was a mixed bag with some
movies that were serious, some farcical and all with a little camp. Destroy All
Monsters is heavy on the camp, maybe too heavy, which prevents it from landing higher
on the list, but for kaiju fans it is a must see, being a veritable who’s who
of 50s and 60s Japanese monsters: Godzilla, King Ghidorah, Rodan, Mothra, Baragon,
Manda, Varan and others.20)- Assignment Terror (Los Monstruos del Terror) (1970)-
Another Paul Naschy film with him as the Wolf Man. In this film, aliens (???)
bring to life a werewolf, a mummy, Frankenstein’s monster and a vampire with a
plan to use them to take over the world, because sure why not. The Wolf Man (who
,interestingly, is always the protagonist in both the Universal films and the
Naschy films) has to fight the other monsters in turn in order to save
humanity. This film is pretty weak compared to Naschy’s other films of the
period, but you have to give credit to the ambitious story.19)-House of Dracula (1945)- The penultimate monster
mash for Universal, it was preceded by House of Frankenstein. Lon Chaney Jr. reprises his role as the
tortured Wolf Man and Glenn Strange returns as Frankenstein’s monster. John
Carradine reprises his role as Dracula and thankfully gets more screen time
than he did in House of Frankenstein. It also features Universal horror
regular, Lionel Atwill.18)- The Robot vs. The Aztec Mummy (1958)- If you are
unfamiliar with Mexican horror, the first thing you need to know is that it
never followed the “rules” of American horror, and nowhere was this more
evident than in the Aztec Mummy trilogy. These films feel like something a
group of kids came up with while hopped up on too much candy and soda. The
final film in the saga features the ever-vengeful Aztec mummy fighting a mad
scientist and his very atompunk looking robot man. Pure fun.
17) Alien vs. Predator (2004)- A film that sort of
gave fans what they wanted while also leaving them wistfully hoping for more.
The premise for this started in the 1989 Dark Horse comic and in typical
Hollywood fashion, they rejected the source material in favor of something
else. Ever since the ending of Predator 2, which showed an Alien skull mounted
as a trophy in a Predator ship, fans had hoped for this match up. Alien vs.
Predator has good looking Aliens and good looking Predators, but it lacked the
punch of the better volumes of either franchise. Pretty much mandatory viewing
for fans of both franchises but most other horror fans can skip it.
16) Dollman vs Demonic Toys (1993)- A crossover
between three different Full Moon films; Dollman (a futuristic cop shrunk to
the size of a GI Joe and played by Tim Thomerson; Demonic Toys, toys powered by
infernal spirits; and Bad Channels a story about reality warping aliens. The
film wouldn’t make a top 10 list of Full Moon features, but is notable for the
comic book like attempt to bring so many properties together.
15) House of Frankenstein (1944)- This film is the
direct sequel to Frankenstein Meets the Wolfman (which appears later on the
list) and features Lon Chaney again as the Wolf Man. This movie is the first of
3 times that Glenn Stange would play Frankenstein’s Monster. John Carradine is
a rather dapper Dracula, who unfortunately gets very little screen time. The
best part though is the addition of Boris Karloff as the antagonist of the story.
A truly fun film for fans of Universal monsters.
14) Underworld: Rise of the Lycans (2009)- This is
the third film in the Underworld franchise and the only one that doesn’t star
Kate Beckinsale. What sets it apart from its leather clad brethren is its
setting, taking place entirely in the Middle Ages. The film attempts to tell
the franchises backstory about how the centuries old war between werewolves and
vampires began. Strong performances from everyone involved and some really nice
black armour for the vampire knights. Even though its best viewed after seeing
Underworld, it’s totally watchable as a stand-alone film.
13) Godzilla vs. Mothra (1992)- In case you’re not
hip to the lingo, about every 15 years, the Godzilla franchise reboots itself
and a new “era” of films begin, with only the original 1954 film remaining in
cannon. The second era, the “Heisei” era, ran through the 80s and 90s and is
notable for creating a single cohesive story that loosely connects all of the
films together. This film features a match
up between Big G and Mothra and is essentially a reboot of the Showa period
film featuring the same match up. It is a technically better made film than its
predecessor and even introduces a new monster, Batra, a sinister version of
Mothra. As good as it is, it’s still a remake and you always get bonus points
for being first, which is why I put it just slightly behind the original.
12) Ghidorah, the Three-Headed Monster (1964)- A true
Godzilla battle royal featuring Godzilla’s most dangerous foe, the three headed
dragon King Ghidorah. But we also get
Rodan and Mothra who team up with Godzilla to beat the evil dragon. A fun film,
it takes itself more seriously than Destroy All Monsters and this really helps
the story. A truly entertaining film and a must see for kaiju fans.11) Mothra vs. Godzilla (1964)- Mothra is one of the
most interesting and bizarre kaiju to come out of the genre. Not only is she
largely a benevolent creature but she is usually accompanied by her two twin
fairies that sort of speak for her. Mothra had previously appeared in her own
1961 film. As it was a huge success, it was only natural that she team up with
Godzilla. Mothra movies are always a little weird and this helps elevate the
match up above most of the other Godzilla movies.10) Werewolf vs The Vampire Woman (La Noche de Walpurgis)
(1970)- The final Paul Naschy film to appear on this list, it is maybe his
best film, and definitely the best of his werewolf movies. In this installment,
the doomed lycanthrope must go against a vampiric queen of the undead. The film is a real masterpiece of 70s horror
featuring beautiful women, spooky ambiances, morbid visuals and Naschy at the
top of his game. Worth seeing even if you are totally unfamiliar with the
franchise or Spanish horror. It’s just a great looking, creepy film.9) Underworld (2003)- Werewolves had been fighting
vampires on screen for almost 60 years by the time this film came out, but no
other film has done it as well, before or since. Underworld tells the story of
Selene, a soldier in the vampire army whose sole reason for existence is to
hunt down and kill their furry enemies. Her un-life gets more complicated when
she falls in love with a mortal who is at the center of a werewolf plot to
destroy the vampires. A super stylish film and Kate Beckinsale is smoking hot
decked out in latex and leather. A must see for fans of the old White Wolf role
playing games.
8) Mad Monster Party? (1967)- Not really a horror
movie as much as a fun homage to horror movies. Mad Monster Party? was brought
to us by Rankin and Bass, the masters of animation that gave us the classic
Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer as well as the 1977 version of The Hobbit and
the 80s dark fantasy The Last Unicorn. The film features a who’s who gathering
of monsters with practically every western horror icon appearing. It also
features the voice of Boris Karloff as the mad scientist organizing the affair.
Mandatory viewing for Halloween, and fun whether you’re 8 or 48.
7) Van Helsing (2004)- Following the success of the first
two Brendan Fraser Mummy films, this was Universal’s next attempt to revitalize
its monster franchises since it closed up shop in the 1950s. Hugh Jackman plays
the titular Van Helsing who teams up with Kate Beckinsale (fresh off the
success of Underworld) to fight Dracula, his Brides, the Wolf Man,
Frankenstein’s Monster and even the Hunchback of Notre Dame. A very stylish
movie that is well made with high production values that refuses to take itself
too seriously. The late 90s/ early 00s was a bit of a low point for horror but
this film has aged better than most of its counterparts of that era.
One
question remains: Stephen Sommers made both the 1999 Mummy and Van Helsing and
both films were successful. Why did we never get Van Helsing vs The Mummy?
6) King Kong vs. Godzilla (1962)-OK, first off ,this
film looks like crap compared to some of the other Godzilla films of the same
era. Godzilla’s design has changed many times, sometimes making Big G look
scarier, sometimes sillier. This design is about middle of the road but it
seems like a Ray Harryhausen sculpt compared to the Kong design, which makes
you wonder if the film makers ever even saw a picture of an actual
gorilla. So how could I have it placed
so high? Because its King Kong verses Godzilla!!! This is the kind of film that
fanboys and fangirls grow up dreaming about! This isn’t the typical Godzilla
crossover with multiple Toho properties meeting under one roof. This was 2
monsters from 2 different film companies from opposite sides of the planet!
This was like putting Ric Flair and Hulk Hogan on the same tag team! Or having
the Avengers fight the Justice Leage!
The film is pure camp, but for lovers of kaiju, it doesn’t
get any more fun than Kong vs. Godzilla.
5) Freddy vs. Jason (2003)- What King Kong vs.
Godzilla was to kaiju fans, Freddy vs. Jason was to slasher fans. Freddy and
Jason were the kings of 80s slasher films (Freddy had 5 films in the 80s while
Jason had 8, compared to Michael who only had 3 in the decade and Leatherface
who only had the 1).
By the 21st century, both franchises had long
since passed their primes but this film gave fans something to get excited
about with a new film that actually offered something creative without simply
relying on nostalgia to carry the story. The most amazing thing about the film
is how faithful it is to both characters. You never get the feeling that either
character has been plucked out of its home franchise and dropped into
unfamiliar lands. The story feels natural and the characters are just as you
remembered them. A great achievement in the annals of slasher film history.
4) Waxwork (1988)-Of the many great horror films of
the video store era, this is one of the best because of its fun, its creativity
and its high production values. The story surrounds a nefarious wax museum run
by a sinister curator (David Warner). A preppy college student (Zach Galligan)
starts nosing around after his sort of girlfriend goes missing after visiting
the museum. What he discovers is that the museum is playing home to real life
monsters whose spirits are stored in the displays.
And what a list of monsters it is: Dracula, a werewolf, a
mummy, the Marquis de Sade, not to mention appearances from Frankenstein’s creature,
zombies, and various murders, monsters and more. There are also appearances by
Miles O’Keefe and John Rhys-Davies. A very entertaining film with good looking
special effects and some memorable monsters.
3) The Monster Squad (1987)- The plot is simple,
Dracula is trying to bring about the end of the world with the help of the Wolf
Man, the Mummy and the Gill Man. All that stands in his way are a group of kids
aided by Frankenstein’s monster.
The film’s strength is its total commitment to being fun.
The kids are likable if occasionally unbelievable and Dracula is thoroughly
evil. Duncan Regehr’s portrayal is very memorable, making his Dracula a little
bit like a Bond villain. The monster effects all look beautiful, especially the
Wolf Man which has a design echoing Hammer’s Curse of the Werewolf. As a bonus,
this movie is totally appropriate for kids. Definitely needs to be on your
Halloween watch list if you are looking for something without sex and (too
much) gore.
2) Frankenstein Meets the Wolfman (1943)- This is the
granddaddy of verses films and really the film that created the blueprint for
monster vs. monster movies. The only reason its not #1 on the list is because
the final film just has so much to offer.
In this film, Lawrence Talbot (dead
after the events of The Wolf Man) is brought back to life and is actually
pretty depressed about it. While most of us might be stoked at a second chance,
all Larry can see is an eternity dealing with the curse of lycanthropy. He
learns about Dr. Frankenstein’s work and reasons that, if Frankenstein can
bring life to the dead, perhaps he can bring death to the seemingly unkillable
Larry (makes sense if you think about it). He soon finds himself coming face to
face with the Monster (played by Bela Lugosi this time (Chaney himself had
played the Monster in the previous Frankenstein film).
Beyond this being the first time
that we ever got to see horror icons face off on the screen, the movie also has
other merits. Lawrence Talbot is a kind of Goth prototype (or at least Emo).
He’s very depressed and suicidal and has no goal beyond escaping his own
miserable existence. While the follow up films, House of Frankenstein and House
of Dracula, are campier and played for fun, this film is more serious.
1) Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein (1948)- The
greatest monster mash of all time! By the mid 40s, Universal horror was on the
decline in popularity and its not difficult to understand why. After the real
world horrors of WW2, audiences just weren’t in the mood for anything morbid.
Horror in general took a back seat to science fiction through most of the 50s.
But the Universals Monsters had
enough left in the tank for one last hoorah and it was brought to us by the
most successful comic act of their time. Abbott and Costello had grown to
monumental popularity during the War (when people needed a laugh more than
ever), and they would be the vehicle to give the Universal Monsters a memorable
send off.
The combination of humor and horror
proved to be potent and popular, spawning several more Abbott and Costello
creature features. For fans of monsters, this is like revisiting a beloved
childhood memory. Lon Chaney Jr. revised his role as the Wolf Man, Glenn
Strange returned for his 3rd appearance as Frankenstein’s Monster
and ,best of all, Bela Lugosi took on the Dracula mantle for the first time
since his 1931 portrayal. The only way this film could possibly have been any
better was if Karloff had been involved somehow, but him playing the Monster
was simply out of the question as he was in his 60s by this point and the role
was very taxing for even a young man.
Of every movie on this list, Abbott
and Costello meet Frankenstein is the absolutely must see film and (I think) a mandatory part of any
October line up.
So
Hollywood, its time for some more monster vs. monster films! Michael vs.
Leatherface, or Gremlins vs. Critters, or Species vs. Aliens, or Chucky vs.
Annabelle or…..